My urologist is old school. We talk. He spends so much time talking with me that his nurses have to remind him that he has other patients. He worries that the new generation of doctors are being trained to read algorithms and not look at the patient. I thought of his concern during a recent physical. During my entire examination the newly minted doctor looked at the computer screen and never made eye contact with me. When he finally left the screen to listen to my heart it felt more like performance than actual examination since the numbers had already told him all he thought he needed to know. To him I am a spreadsheet. He seeks patterns in my numbers, both present and past. My beating heart is secondary.
Pattern recognition is useful. And, sometimes it is not. “In humans, heavy reliance on pattern recognition can cause pareidolia (seeing patterns or faces in random noise), confirmation bias, or faulty cause-and-effect assumptions.” My urologist assures me that the latest and greatest imagining software has not actually improved his capacity to diagnose disease, especially in patients like me. I am an anomaly. He tells me that my body did not read the handbook. My patterns deceive. Had I been treated by the numbers I would not be here.
I left the impression with Skip that I am anti-technology but I am not. Without technology I would not be able to write these posts. I am alive today because of technology in the form of medical intervention. My urologist calls me a miracle of modern medicine and that makes me a great fan of technology. I am also a fan of human intuition because his intuitive skills were key in diagnosing what the numbers could not. He looked at me. He talked with me. It took the meeting of human intuition and technology to produce the modern miracle of my life.
Amidst our technological world I remain a fan of Socrates: “…gaining a powerful external tool often means losing an internal human skill.” Who doesn’t want their doctor to see them as a human being and not a series of numbers? Both are possible at the same time. Am I alone in thinking that profit-driven-assembly-line-healthcare has lost its way? What happened to the importance of relationship between doctor and patient?
Socrates also offers this to the technologists, the Peter Thiels, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musks of the world, : The inventor of a tool is rarely the best judge of its harm or benefit. (Plato, Phaedrus). In this world of AI and the daily inundation of technological wonders, with the makers and purveyors both singing its praises and warning of its dangers, it is generous to suggest that they benefit either way. It requires the rest of us to judge through experience what is gained and what is lost and, hopefully, over time, find a balance between the two.
A healthy skepticism is, well, healthy.
read Kerri’s blogpost about ZIGZAG
likesharecommentsupport.thankyou!
Filed under: Pattern, Perspective, Two Artists Tuesday, Uncategorized | Tagged: algorithms, artistry, confirmation bias, david robinson, davidrobinsoncreative.com, healthcare, Kerri Sherwood, kerri sherwood itunes, kerrianddavid.com, kerrisherwood.com, pattern, plato, relationship, socrates, story, studio melange, technology, the melange | Leave a comment »




























