A Healthy Skepticism [David’s blog on Two Artists Tuesday]

My urologist is old school. We talk. He spends so much time talking with me that his nurses have to remind him that he has other patients. He worries that the new generation of doctors are being trained to read algorithms and not look at the patient. I thought of his concern during a recent physical. During my entire examination the newly minted doctor looked at the computer screen and never made eye contact with me. When he finally left the screen to listen to my heart it felt more like performance than actual examination since the numbers had already told him all he thought he needed to know. To him I am a spreadsheet. He seeks patterns in my numbers, both present and past. My beating heart is secondary.

Pattern recognition is useful. And, sometimes it is not. “In humans, heavy reliance on pattern recognition can cause pareidolia (seeing patterns or faces in random noise), confirmation bias, or faulty cause-and-effect assumptions.” My urologist assures me that the latest and greatest imagining software has not actually improved his capacity to diagnose disease, especially in patients like me. I am an anomaly. He tells me that my body did not read the handbook. My patterns deceive. Had I been treated by the numbers I would not be here.

I left the impression with Skip that I am anti-technology but I am not. Without technology I would not be able to write these posts. I am alive today because of technology in the form of medical intervention. My urologist calls me a miracle of modern medicine and that makes me a great fan of technology. I am also a fan of human intuition because his intuitive skills were key in diagnosing what the numbers could not. He looked at me. He talked with me. It took the meeting of human intuition and technology to produce the modern miracle of my life.

Amidst our technological world I remain a fan of Socrates: “…gaining a powerful external tool often means losing an internal human skill.” Who doesn’t want their doctor to see them as a human being and not a series of numbers? Both are possible at the same time. Am I alone in thinking that profit-driven-assembly-line-healthcare has lost its way? What happened to the importance of relationship between doctor and patient?

Socrates also offers this to the technologists, the Peter Thiels, Jeff Bezos and Elon Musks of the world, : The inventor of a tool is rarely the best judge of its harm or benefit. (Plato, Phaedrus). In this world of AI and the daily inundation of technological wonders, with the makers and purveyors both singing its praises and warning of its dangers, it is generous to suggest that they benefit either way. It requires the rest of us to judge through experience what is gained and what is lost and, hopefully, over time, find a balance between the two.

A healthy skepticism is, well, healthy.

read Kerri’s blogpost about ZIGZAG

likesharecommentsupport.thankyou!

Look Beneath The Brag [on DR Thursday]

“If I don’t brag I can’t complain,” she said, eyes sparkling. I howled with laughter. Wisdom from a soon-to-be 101 year old.

There’s nothing like a long life to strip the paint off an ego.

Her wisdom launched me into a thought-jag and made me wonder what a little time and maturity might bring to our yammering social media streams. Of LinkedIn a colleague recently said, “Everyone is selling. No one is buying.” Lots of bragging balanced by lots of complaining. Although it is moving fast, social media is still very, very young. A raucous kindergarten class. Me. Me. Me!

Kerri and I are not above it, of course. We are knee-deep in it. Each day we bemoan, “Oh, if only our readers would like or share our posts or music or cartoon or paintings…” The algorithm of “like” makes braggers and beggars of us all. It’s the road to increased attention which transmogrifies into words like “influencer” which promises dollars (with or without sense). (sorry. i couldn’t help myself;-) We don’t really want to be influencers but we do really want our work to support us – just like everyone else – so, a conundrum. In current reality, a full spectrum of bragging and complaining marks the road to increased notice.

Marshall McLuhan famously said, “The medium is the message.” Said another way, “…the content of any medium blinds us to the character of the medium.” Content need not have substance in a fast moving medium creating so many squeaky wheels seeking grease. Character (noun): mental and moral qualities… Through our current medium it is necessary to scream loud. No substance or moral quality is required to garner attention since garnering attention is the end-goal. Complain! Brag! Bang pots! Cry wolf! Blow whistles! Break news! Spread conspiracy! Lie loudly… Thumbs up. Angry face. Heart.

It brought again to my mind the question Susan asked last week, “When did kindness leave…” What I wish I’d said is, “It’s still there, it’s just runs deep beneath the noise.” Kindness has no need to compete with complaint for attention.

“How did it get to be the middle of August already?” Kerri asked, focusing her camera on the fading coneflowers. The day was hot. We were overwhelmed by our tasks so took a break and went for a walk.

“I don’t know,” I replied, trying to remember all that happened in June and July. There were so many life altering events for our friends and family. With no air in our sail, becalmed, time has lost much of its meaning.

Kerri showed me her photo. “I think I’ll call this one Waning Summer.” For us, there’s nothing to brag about so there’s nothing to complain about. Thank goodness. We sit solidly in the middle of the spectrum, knowing somewhere, running deep beneath the noise and moving very slowly, like kindness, runs a mighty river of gratitude.

“It’s beautiful.” I said.

like. support. share. comment. thank you.

chasing bubbles, 33.25 x 48IN mixed media © david robinson

visit my gallery site

read Kerri’s thoughts about END OF SEASON

Get Some Perspective [on Not So Flawed Wednesday]

“Oh, god…I feel a fit of moralizing coming on….” ~ Words to myself, uttered just a moment ago.

This would seem like a no-duh: perspective requires distance. Said another way: to see the mountain, one cannot be standing atop of the mountain.

Much to Kerri’s dismay, I think out loud about these things. A lot. She has to listen to my ruminating. Marriage requires her to be in the same space with me and I talk endlessly about the things rattling through my mind. Just ask her. Let’s just say she has no distance from my incessant blather so she lacks perspective. Or, her capacity to ignore my noise is the result of experience which provides her solid perspective. Don’t ask me. I am not in the position to offer an opinion.

When you dip your mind into the pool of information technology as I have, it’s nearly impossible to NOT think about the absence of perspective. Actually, if you read or listen to the news-of-the-day or take a swim in the social media cesspool, and are able to step back from it (thereby creating some distance), you’ll find that meaningful perspective has long ago fled the building.

For years I’ve been reading about the pace of change. At some point – and we’ve arrived at that point – the event horizon (that which enables perspective) is no longer in front of us. We sit on top of it. Information comes too fast and without pause. And, often without substance. Without perspective, the context of our lives is as fleeting and changeable as “Breaking News” or the latest posts on social media. Since the algorithms are driven by the most “likes” not the most relevant, the ugliest and loudest noise-makers garner the most attention and dominate the air-time (thank goodness for cute pet posts providing some humor in the onslaught).

Attention-getting is not known for its grounding in solid perspective. Just ask the boy who cried wolf.

As we know, crying wolf works well – for a while. Attention-getting is addictive. Once hooked, people will do or say anything to keep their buzz going. Sitting directly atop the event horizon, the only way to keep the attention is, of course, to scream louder and louder. Escalate the outrage. A news cycle churns as fast as the social media stream. Remember: the algorithms are not based on meaningful substance but on the ability to grab attention. Louder/uglier wins the day.

Without perspective, escalating outrage – the loudest and nastiest train wreck – will always win the attention grab. It’s human nature. We sort to the negative. It’s why we share complaints with anyone who will listen but dribble-out the good news to a select few.

There is an important disappearance that accompanies the loss of perspective: crap-detecting. Awash as we are in a raucous bluster of vapidness, the only hope we have is to take a step back and question. To descend from the event horizon and ask, “Is this or that assertion true?” Or, is it meant to make me mad, fuel my anger? Is it tailor-made for my perspective-less bubble?

Stepping back, gaining perspective, asking relevant questions. Crap-detecting. If a better world is what we desire to create, dedicated crap-detecting is the necessary first step in being-the-change we wish to make.

read Kerri’s blogpost on PERSPECTIVE